Boutique OWI/DUI defense, by design.

Cafferty & Scheidegger has defended OWI and DUI cases across southeast Wisconsin since 1994. We are not a volume practice. Every case gets a named attorney, direct access, and a defense strategy built for that case, not a template pulled from a drawer.

One attorney, one case, start to finish

At larger firms, your OWI file moves from an intake paralegal to a junior associate to whoever is available on your court date. You explain your situation three times and still nobody knows the details.

We work differently. The attorney you speak with on your first call is the same attorney who reviews the squad video, files the suppression motion, negotiates with the DA, and stands next to you in court. That continuity matters. Your attorney catches the detail in the officer’s report that contradicts the dashcam, because they read both.

When you have a question about your IID installation or your upcoming court date, you reach a lawyer who knows your case. Not a voicemail tree.

Deep roots in three counties

Our headquarters at 840 Lake Avenue in Racine is six blocks from the Racine County Courthouse. We have appeared in every branch of the criminal division for over 30 years. Our second office at 7001 30th Avenue in Kenosha is minutes from the Kenosha County Courthouse. The Walworth County courthouse in Elkhorn is a 45-minute drive from our Racine office, a route we travel regularly.

Three decades in these courthouses means we understand how each county’s system works: the procedural rhythms, the calendaring patterns, and the prosecution posture that shapes case outcomes.

  • Racine County: our home courthouse. OWI/Drug Treatment Court, intake calendars Monday and Thursday, Branches 1–10.
  • Kenosha County: border county with Illinois. Illinois DUI convictions count as priors under §343.307 (10-year window at the 2nd-offense tier, back to January 1, 1989 at 3rd-and-above tiers). Branches I–VIII.
  • Walworth County: Lake Geneva tourism drives seasonal OWI enforcement spikes. Elkhorn courthouse, frequent OWI calendar.

OWI and DUI: same offense, different name

Wisconsin calls it OWI (Operating While Intoxicated). Illinois calls it DUI. If you were arrested in Kenosha or Walworth County after crossing the border from Illinois, you are facing a Wisconsin OWI charge, and your Illinois DUI history counts. Under §346.65(2)(am), Illinois DUIs count toward a Wisconsin 2nd offense when they fall within 10 years of the new violation, and toward a 3rd or 4th offense all the way back to January 1, 1989. We audit mixed-state prior counts regularly because a misclassified prior can drop a charge by an entire offense tier.

What we handle

This site covers the OWI/DUI side of our practice: from first-offense civil forfeitures to Class H felony fourth-offenses, plus refusal hearings, CDL cases, OWI with a minor passenger, and underage absolute-sobriety violations.

For non-OWI criminal defense (drug charges, domestic violence, violent crime, federal charges, municipal tickets) visit our full-service site at racinelaw.com.

Your defense team

Every case is worked directly by a named attorney from first call through final disposition. You will never be handed off to a paralegal or rotated through associates. Your attorney knows your case because they built it.

Patrick K. Cafferty, founding partner and OWI/DUI defense attorney in Racine, Wisconsin

Patrick K. Cafferty

Founding Partner

Marquette Law graduate defending OWI and criminal cases across southeast Wisconsin for over 32 years. Named a Wisconsin Super Lawyer® 18 consecutive years and rated AV Preeminent® by Martindale-Hubbell.

Full bio →
Jillian J. Scheidegger, partner handling OWI/DUI and criminal defense across southeast Wisconsin

Jillian J. Scheidegger

Partner

Partner since 2013 handling criminal defense and OWI matters for adults and juveniles. Marquette Law graduate, Wisconsin Super Lawyer®, and President-Elect of the Racine County Bar Association.

Full bio →
Carl Johnson, OWI/DUI trial attorney practicing in Racine, Kenosha, and Walworth counties

Carl Johnson

Attorney

Marquette Law 2006, UW–Madison undergrad. Extensive trial experience including first-degree homicide and sexual assault defense. Racine native practicing in Racine, Kenosha, and Walworth counties.

Full bio →
Juan S. Ramirez, bilingual OWI/DUI defense attorney and former public defender

Juan S. Ramirez

Attorney

Michigan State Law graduate and former Racine County Public Defender. Bilingual English/Spanish. Won the WACDL Hanson Memorial Advocate Prize for a homicide acquittal. Advises on how criminal charges affect immigration status.

Full bio →
Over 30 years of OWI/DUI defense awards and recognitions at Cafferty & Scheidegger

Recognition

  • Wisconsin Super Lawyers®, 18 consecutive years (Patrick Cafferty)
  • AV Preeminent® rated by Martindale-Hubbell
  • Best Law Office in Racine, 2025
  • 4.9★ rating across 636+ Google reviews
  • WACDL Hanson Memorial Advocate Prize (Juan Ramirez)
  • Racine County Bar Association President-Elect (Jillian Scheidegger)

Talk to us

Consultations are free, confidential, and available 24/7. Call now or fill out the form. A named attorney will respond, not a receptionist.